Showing posts with label WiMAX. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WiMAX. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

The Netscape of Mobile Broadband: Killer Applications Drive Diffusion

In this post I will present a framework I've developed to explain how "Killer Applications" are key to driving the diffusion of what I'd like to call "Platform Technologies". This week I've had the opportunity to correspond with Professor Shane Greenstein (Kellogg School of Management) about the history of PC and Internet diffusion. His knowledge has helped flesh out some of my thinking and provided additional examples to back-up my ideas.

A "Platform Technology" is a technology, that serves as the basis for many other technologies. For example, the PC is a platform on which you run spreadsheets, type documents, and do any other type of computing activities you might enjoy. On its own, a PC is not very useful, but when running the right applications, it is very powerful.

A "Killer Application" is that first, incredibly valuable and easy to use application that when paired with a platform technology is the source of the value for users. It is these applications that are the impetus for rapid technology diffusion.

There is a host of academic research to back this claim up. I'll focus on the technology diffusion theories of Everett Rogers, F.D. Davis, and Geoffrey Moore.

Everett Rodgers (in addition to introducing the S-shaped diffusion curve) described a potential user's decision to adopt a technology as follows:



In words, he proved that as a new product becomes easier to use, the product's compatibility with existing products increases, and relative advantage over other products increases, consumers are more likely to adopt the product. On the other hand, as the complexity of the product increases, the less likely users are to adopt the technology.

F.D. Davis introduced a variant on Rogers's model. The Technology Acceptance Model states:



That is, ease of use drives utility and both drive technological adoption.

Lastly, Geoffrey Moore, built on Rogers's S-shaped diffusion curve to introduce the idea of "chasms" between market segments in the adoption timeline.



First, "innovators" would use the technology, basically, because it was new and cool. Next, "the early adopters" would adopt the technology because they could imagine the possibilities that the technology would offer. The 3rd and most critical market segment would then be the "the early majority." This group would be the market segment that would finally have a significant effect on the profitability of the new technology. Once they begin to use the technology, diffusion will reach the "tipping point" and accelerate. But, there is a catch. The early majority needs to see a significant and concrete value proposition in order to adopt. Moore, cites many examples of technologies that failed to demonstrate this for the early majority and thus fell into a chasm.

Why have I bored you with all this academic research? Because it is very informative not just for mobile broadband in Latin America, but throughout the world. I'd like to expand on my framework of platform technologies to discuss the diffusion of the PC and Internet and then tie that in with mobile broadband.

For many years, the computer held little value for the majority of market segments. Its use was restricted to academia and hobbyists. The memory and processing capabilities of the platform continued to improve, but this did not translate into value for the consumer. Then came the killer application of Visicalc in 1982.



This improved value and ease of use for the business segment and spurred wide adoption among the early majority of the business user segment.

The next chapter comes in 1984, when processing capabilities allowed for the WIMP (Window Icon Menu Pointing Device) interface.



The new, simple interface increased the ease of use and thus value of computers for the home user segment. The new value proposition carried the PC over the chasm between early adopters and the early majority.

Now, rather than discuss the Internet separately, I'd like to think of the connectedness and bandwidth of the Internet as an extension of the capabilities of the computing platform. That is, in addition to the ability to process information, the Internet introduced a new capability vector: sending and receiving information. Armed with these new capabilities, the computing platform just needed a new, killer application to take advantage of all its capabilities. That came in 1971, with the introduction of email applications.



By now, this is a familiar story. Email significantly increased the value of the platform for the academic segment and technical users. This led to a first wave of adoption on the Internet.

More dramatic was the introduction of graphical web browsers (Mosaic, Netscape.) They are perhaps the best example of a killer application.



Their introduction created so much value for consumers, that the Internet's rapid diffusion was described by Bill Gates as a "tidal wave."

That brings us to today and mobile broadband. My argument is that the mobility of WiMAX and LTE is another capability vector for the computing platform. Now, we can process, send and receive data, and do it while moving. The problem is that up until now, we do not have a killer application that takes advantage of all three capabilities. In order to drive adoption and avoid Moore's chasms, we need either a new application (or even device) to increase ease of use, and utility of mobile broadband. The iPhone has certainly done some of that, but we need something more. Mapping and location based services show promise, but no products currently stand out.



Yeah, so when I think of that product, I'll stop blogging and start raising venture cap.

References:
Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technology. MIS Quarterly, 13(3), 319-339.
Rogers, Everett M. Diffusion of Innovations. 4th ed. New York: Free Press, 1995
Moore, Geoffrey A. Crossing the Chasm. New York: Harper Collins, 2002.

Monday, February 16, 2009

New Opportunity for the Mobile Internet via IPv6 or v7?

One of the most interesting opportunities for mobile broadband is to better incorporate the mobility capabilities into new applications. In the last post, I discuss how mobile broadband is a platform to deliver value across the its 3 main capabilities: 1) Information processing 2) Information transfer 3) Mobility.

There is precedence for this. The PC was a platform for information processing. It delivered maximum value after the introduction of the killer application Visicalc (spreadsheets.) The Internet was a platform for information processing and transfer. It had two waves of diffusion. The first came when email or file transfer applications delivered increased value. The second came when the Internet delivered a new wave of value after the introduction of the killer applications Mosaic and Netscape (graphics based browsers.) Today, wireless broadband can be a platform for mobile information processing and transfer. We are still waiting to see what killer application will deliver value by taking advantage of all three capabilities. Location based services? Something else I haven't thought of?

I was reading an interesting article in the NY times today:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/15/weekinreview/15markoff.html


There is all this new effort to design a new, more secure Internet - basically through new protocols like IPv6. Early indications seem to point to a future Internet where, in exchange for more security, we give up some of our anonymity. Bad news for the libertarian pioneers of the open internet (sorry Richard Stallman) but potentially good news for new emerging Internet technologies (you are welcome LTE and WiMAX.) New Internet protocols could standardize a platform incorporating mobility into the next iteration of the Internet applications. At this point, it sounds like mostly government and academic researchers are shaping the protocols. I wonder how long until AT&T, Clearwire, Intel and the other big stakeholders try to make their voices heard.

Friday, November 21, 2008

ROI for building the network

Based on information that I have been gathering, I think that this week will be dedicated to calculating the Return on Investment for building a WiMAX network in LATM.

The key here will be to identify revenue that would not have been earned with existing infrastructure. In other words, I will need to look at 1) the increase in ARPU from the WiMAX network and 2) all the revenue from new customers (these will likely be the fixed users.) Lastly, I will need to subtract any revenue lost to cannibalization. That is, I'll need to make some assumptions about how much less users will be talking if they are sending IMs.

I have a lot of data that will help me estimate these numbers - Laptop penetration, smartphone penetration, total population, diffusion patterns - but I will also need to make some assumptions. How much will these new markets increase spending on service if given access to broadband data services? How will they react as prices come down? How will competitors behave? How long until these networks become obsolete? And many more assumptions.

Because of the assumptions I need to make, I do not anticipate my forecasts to be the be-all-end-all to the financial calculations on this business model. Instead, my hope is that I will provide a suitible methodology so that others can refine my assumptions and form a more accurate financial picture of this business.

Saturday, October 4, 2008

Research for the upcoming quarter

So, my last couple posts have been basically statement of purpose papers pasted into a blog. From here on out, posts will be less formal and more focused on what I'm researching and my methodology. That said, I'll get down to business.

I left things off with a paper last year discussing the overall business model for a WiMAX telco. I touched on diffusion (demand), costs (supply), and other technology (substitutes.) Clearly all of these issues will be a factor for a business selling WiMAX, but now I want to focus on demand in Latin America. Specifically, I want to answer the question: How can companies package and price wireless, mobile broadband products in a way that will create and capture value in Latin America?

This approach, I believe has several advantages to looking at the broad business plan of WiMAX in Latin America.

First, I don't think I can add a lot of value in assessing the cost side of this business. The cost of deploying a WiMAX network is something that is well understood by the engineers at telecos and equipment manufacturers. Given, my business training, I can predict trends for these costs (lower costs as the technology moves down the learning curve, lower costs in developing markets where telecos have low margins.) But my contributions in this area would not be especially useful.

I also want to avoid getting into a protracted discussion of WiMAX vs. LTE vs. 802.11n. The standard of choice is, of course, very important to companies investing in infrastructure. However, from my perspective, the important thing is that long-range, wireless broadband will become available in the next five years and someone will be selling that service.

I want to understand, what products (service configurations) at what prices companies should offer in Latin America. I see three potential sources of information that will inform my research and conclusions:

1. Research on market entry in Latin America. There has been much literature written recently on "Bottom of the Pyramid" business opportunities. Papers discussing entry into Latin America will be useful - especially if they discuss entry of services. By analyzing how companies have successfully adapted and priced service offerings for the Latin American market, I hope to identify patterns and strategies that can be applied to wireless broadband service.

2. Research on the internet service pricing throughout the world. There is a large body of literature discussing various pricing strategies for internet service - especially in lieu of the net-neutrality debate. Wireless broadband service prices will clearly be informed by last ten years of pricing strategies by ISPs throughout the world.

3. Current mobile phone services and pricing in Latin America. Maybe this should be first. In order to understand how LATM telcos must change, we need to understand where they are starting from. A survey of what products and pricing are currently offered will serve as the base from which I hope to see how the companies need to evolve.
 
Creative Commons License
This work by John Jacob Bradbury is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.